World Rugby has suspended South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus for six matches over comments about referees made after his team’s defeat by France in the Nations Championship last week. The sanction was issued under the procedure for sanctioning attacks on referees, which the governing body introduced in July.
Erasmus spoke at a press conference in Dublin on Monday, ahead of the Springboks’ match against Ireland. The conference lasted more than half an hour in the South African team’s hotel space. Erasmus then questioned what he described as double standards in refereeing, asking: "isn't that match-fixing?" He referred to the application of new rules on hook and knee tackles, arguing that they were not being enforced correctly.
The context of his remarks was the case of Irish opener Sam Prendergast, the first player reported for a hook tackle in Ireland’s victory over Fiji on Saturday. That tackle was not penalised by referee Angus Gardner and television assistant referee Mike Adamson during the game. Erasmus stated that 17 such tackles had escaped the referees in South Africa’s 21-19 defeat by France, with the referee at the Stade de France being Andrea Piardi and the TMO Matteo Liperini.
Erasmus added that if TMOs do not intervene for a review to limit the number of stoppages in a match, it represents "manipulation". He emphasised that his statements were "not an accusation". "If he didn't see it, then it's a problem with the technology. If he saw it and decided not to act, isn't that match-fixing?", Erasmus said. "If the TMO didn't see it, maybe the technology needs to be better. If he saw it and ignored it, what does that come down to? To manipulating the game or the result, or to injured players getting further injured", he added. "All I am asking is that TMOs are not excluded or discouraged from getting involved. Then the wrong team will win and players will get injured. That is all I am saying", he concluded.
World Rugby stated on Tuesday that an independent panel had determined that Erasmus’s comments had reached the "threshold of a serious breach". According to the statement, the panel concluded that the comments "suggest that the referees acted with bias or prejudice, or that they deliberately influenced the outcome of the match", and that a reasonable person, considering the conduct as a whole, would conclude that it represented an unacceptable attack on the credibility and competence of the referees. "The panel found that the conduct clearly represents a disrespect of the authority of the referees because it questions their integrity", it stated. The panel reviewed a number of elements of the comments, including the timing and scope of the statements, along with allegations of bias or bad faith, and concluded that the comments warranted an automatic six-match suspension.
World Rugby said that "respect is the foundation of rugby, and referees are at the heart of the sport". "Protecting their welfare and integrity, as well as their right to work without abuse or intimidation, is a responsibility that World Rugby and unions take seriously", the statement read. It added that "coaches, players, unions and everyone in the game must respect these standards". "Strong and respectful debate is natural, but teams have access to well-established and supported channels and protocols for raising refereeing issues before and after matches. Questioning a decision is not the same as questioning a referee's integrity or making comments that expose them to personal abuse", it stated.
The South African Rugby Union stated that it had requested a full hearing on the breach. They asked for the opportunity for Erasmus to "contextualise his comments and convince the panel that it was not his intention to claim that any referee acted with hidden motives".
This is the third time World Rugby has sanctioned Erasmus over comments about referees. While he was director of rugby for South Africa, he was suspended for two months after publishing a one-hour video criticising refereeing in the Springboks’ defeat by the British and Irish Lions in the first test in 2021. World Rugby then found that the video contained "numerous offensive and derogatory comments and attacks on referees". In 2022, he received a two-match ban for a series of social media posts in which he criticised referees in a defeat by France.
If the suspension remains in force, Erasmus will miss Saturday’s match against Ireland in Dublin (16:40 GMT), then the final weekend of the competition next week at Allianz Stadium in Twickenham, and the start of the Rugby Championship campaign next summer. The ban includes an inability to coach, direct or indirect contact with team management or players on match day, and entry to the stadium, the coaching box, the playing area or the technical area.
At the same press conference, Erasmus also questioned what he considered double standards in sanctions. The outcome of the report for the hook tackle has not yet been published, and Erasmus predicted that Prendergast would be able to play against South Africa due to a "technicality". He also questioned the decision not to penalise an Irish forward.













